Educational Benefits and Ethical Boundaries of Artificial Intelligence (AI): A Comparative Study in the Light of the Methodologies of Fatawa Naeemia and Khair al-Fatawa
مصنوعی ذہانت (AI) کے تدریسی فوائد اور اخلاقی حدود: فتاویٰ نعیمیہ اور خیر الفتاویٰ کے مناہج کی روشنی میں ایک تقابلی مطالعہ
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.68696/qb831z86Keywords:
Artificial Intelligence in Education, Pedagogical Innovation, Academic Integrity, Differentiated Instruction, Educational JurisprudenceAbstract
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly restructuring contemporary instructional frameworks. This critical review evaluates the dual-faceted impact of AI across educational settings, balancing transformative pedagogical advantages against pressing ethical challenges. Operationally, AI automates administrative tasks and streamlines lesson planning. Pedagogically, generative systems empower educators to deliver differentiated instruction at scale, tailoring complex curricula to varied cognitive levels and stimulating critical inquiry. Conversely, widespread adoption presents profound ethical and operational vulnerabilities. Core risks include algorithmic bias, privacy infractions, and the erosion of academic integrity. Additionally, emerging jurisdictional issues surround intellectual property and copyright, raising questions regarding the ownership of machine-generated academic works. Excessive reliance on automated tools further threatens authentic human mentorship, risking cognitive atrophy when procedural convenience replaces rigorous intellectual effort. To mitigate these hazards, this paper advocates for a calibrated, governance-first strategy. Institutions must establish clear policies defining AI strictly as a cognitive supplement. Prioritizing human oversight ensures educators leverage algorithmic efficiency while preserving the foundational integrity and core human value of academic learning.



